Videos

Hickok45 Breaks Down Which Guns Actually Appreciate in Value

November 21, 2026

Hickok45 takes a break from the usual plinking to answer a question he says he hears constantly: are guns actually a good investment? Using his own collection as props, he walks through three categories of firearms and compares their real-world appreciation to what the same money would have earned in the stock market.

Snapshot

In this video, hickok45 sorts firearms into rare/limited-edition pieces, ordinary modern guns, and Class III machine guns, then weighs each against the long-term average return of the S&P 500. His takeaway is blunt: most of what people buy at the gun store isn't going to make them money, though a few narrow categories genuinely can.

Key points

  • Machine guns win on scarcity. Hickok45 cites figures suggesting Class III firearms, restricted by law and limited in supply, can appreciate roughly 7 to 15 percent annually, putting them in S&P territory.
  • Collectibles and antiques hold up well. He points to pieces like his 1883 Cavalry Colt, a 300-unit Long Branch Colt, and discontinued Marlin "JM" models as examples where limited runs or age support real value growth.
  • Modern guns lag badly. Running numbers on his Glock 19, he notes that a decade-old purchase around $550 would need to be worth roughly $1,500 to match compounded market returns, but used Glocks sell for far less.
  • AR-15s and similar guns fare no better. He argues mass-produced modern firearms simply can't match an index fund's long-term compounding, even over many years.
  • Enjoyment counts for something. Hickok45 says he's fine with guns that don't appreciate much since he's "investing" in the shooting experience itself, not just resale value.

Quick take

It's a refreshingly honest gut-check from a guy with decades of trigger time and a serious collection to back up the comparisons. Nobody's getting rich flipping a Glock, but as hickok45 lays out, the right vintage piece or limited run might actually be worth something down the road.

Watch the full video: hickok45