Judge rules felon's shooting was self-defense—but gun charge still stands
An Illinois judge found that a convicted felon was justified in shooting and killing a woman in self-defense last July—then convicted him of the separate crime of being a felon with a gun.
Snapshot
Edward Massey, 36, was acquitted of second-degree murder in the death of ReKeea T. Jackson-Mason but found guilty of possessing a firearm as a felon. Judge John "Mo" Madonia ruled Massey faced a genuine, violent threat and that firing one shot wasn't excessive, yet state and federal law still barred Massey from touching the gun that saved him. Sentencing is set for mid-January, per Bearing Arms.
Key points
- The ruling: Madonia called Massey's belief that he needed to defend himself reasonable and the shooting justified, according to Bearing Arms.
- The injuries: Massey suffered an arm gash, a back contusion, a busted nose and a cut lip requiring stitches, which the judge said "weren't superficial."
- Murky gun origin: Massey testified the gun fell during the fight and he grabbed it, telling police it was a "gift from God," though the judge noted he'd had a chance to arm himself at home instead.
- The penalty: Despite the self-defense finding, Massey faces two to ten years in prison for felon-in-possession, with Illinois law allowing him to serve half that term.
- The columnist's take: Bearing Arms' Cam Edwards argues Massey shouldn't have had to choose between surviving an attack and returning to prison, and suggests he pursue rights restoration if his only disqualifier is a drug conviction.
Quick take
This case lays out the uncomfortable gap in self-defense law: justified use of force doesn't erase separate firearm charges tied to prior convictions. For gun owners, it's a reminder that "the shooting was legal" and "the gun was legal" are two entirely different questions, especially in a state like Illinois.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com