Firearms

Worn Underwood M1 Carbine Shoots Sub-3-Inch Groups at 100 Yards

November 15, 2026

The M1 Carbine gets dismissed as a plinker with a reputation for so-so accuracy, but a hands-on review from GunsAmerica makes the case that a well-worn example can still shoot better than its reputation suggests.

Snapshot

GunsAmerica put a battered Underwood M1 Carbine through its paces and came away impressed, with the rifle producing 2.5 to 3-inch groups at 100 yards. The author frames this as evidence that the platform's reputation for mediocre accuracy is overstated, while also praising the carbine's light weight and quick handling.

Key points

  • Accuracy: The reviewed Underwood carbine shot 2.5 to 3-inch groups at 100 yards, numbers the author presents as solid for a battlefield-worn rifle of this type.
  • Reputation check: GunsAmerica directly challenges the carbine's longstanding reputation for only mediocre accuracy, arguing the results tell a different story.
  • Handling: The article highlights the M1 Carbine's light weight and fast-handling nature as a major strength, decades after its WWII debut.
  • Historical pedigree: The Underwood manufacturing background and the rifle's worn condition add to the review's appeal, tying the shooting results to a tangible piece of history.

Quick take

This is the kind of review that matters more to actual owners than another history lecture on the M1 Carbine's WWII service. A specific, battered example producing sub-3-inch groups is a useful data point if you're deciding whether to trust an old carbine on the range or just hang it on the wall. Worth a look if you're shopping for one or already own one and want to know what to expect.

Read the full story: gunsamerica.com