Fifth Circuit Extends Second Amendment to Gun Sales, Not Just Ownership
A Fifth Circuit panel just ruled that the Second Amendment isn't only about owning guns — it also covers buying and selling them, a decision that could reshape how firearms commerce laws get challenged across Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi.
Snapshot
The ruling came in U.S. v. Deare, a case involving a man charged with illegally dealing firearms without a federal license. The three-judge panel reversed a lower court's refusal to dismiss the indictment and sent the case back for another look, putting states in the circuit on notice about restricting gun sales.
Key points
- The case: Jeremiah Deare was indicted for conspiring to deal firearms without a license and for false statements on dealer records; the panel didn't clear him but ordered the district court to reconsider his motion to dismiss.
- Ho's concurrence: Judge James Ho argued that constitutional rights mean nothing if the government can simply ban the means of exercising them, comparing it to claiming the First Amendment doesn't protect booksellers.
- Oldham's pushback: Judge Andrew Oldham criticized the court's earlier Peterson ruling for stretching Bruen's footnote nine into a broad "presumption of constitutionality," calling the leap from carry licenses to firearm sales a jump "from football to baseball to ballroom dance."
- The dissent: Judge Catharina Hayne argued the Second Amendment's text doesn't mention sellers, so she doesn't believe they're covered — and even if they were, she saw no unconstitutional conduct here.
Quick take
Split panel, split reasoning, but the majority's bottom line matters: commerce in firearms is now squarely a Second Amendment issue in the Fifth Circuit, not just a regulatory afterthought. Expect this to get cited fast in future challenges to dealer licensing and sales restrictions.
Read the full story: TTAG News Contributor