SCOTUS Dodges 22 Gun-Rights Cases on Prohibited Persons
The Supreme Court cleared its docket of 22 Second Amendment cases in a single morning on November 9, leaving every challenged prohibited-person law on the books, according to Bearing Arms columnist Tom Knighton.
Snapshot
Knighton's piece walks through AmmoLand's review of the Court's November 9 orders list, which denied cert in 16 felon-gun-ban challenges plus cases touching a DUI-based gun ban, a federal indictment-related firearm restriction, and a lifetime ban tied to a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction. No justice noted a dissent, and the same orders list cleared the Solicitor General to join gun owners in the upcoming December 2 AR-15 ban arguments.
Key points
- Mass denial: The Court turned away 22 Second Amendment petitions at once, per AmmoLand's review cited in the article, with zero noted dissents.
- Named cases: Denied petitions included Foster v. United States and Barge v. United States (nonviolent felony gun bans), Holloway v. Brown (Washington's misdemeanor-DUI ban), Trevino v. United States (18 U.S.C. § 922(n), the under-indictment ban), and Minor v. United States (lifetime ban from a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction).
- Mostly § 922(g)(1): Most felon-ban challenges targeted the federal law barring possession by anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year in prison.
- AR-15 cases proceed: The Court is still taking up rifle-ban arguments on December 2, even as it avoids prohibited-person questions.
Quick take
Knighton argues the lack of dissent suggests the justices simply saw no need to weigh in, not that these laws are constitutionally sound. He notes the Court's Rahimi ruling makes him unsurprised the justices passed on Minor, even though he personally disagrees with the outcome.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com